J.J. McCarthy
Rebuild 75 vs win-now 40. Protect the timeline — this is not a contender upgrade.
- For contenders
- No forced move for contenders at this price.
- For rebuilders
- Fine rebuild hold (75/100). No forced move.
- In Superflex
- Worth meaningfully more in Superflex (+16 vs 1QB).
- Outlook
- We expect this value to hold — no forced move either way.
- Risk
- Low risk profile (19.9/100).
Rebuild 75 vs win-now 40. Protect the timeline — this is not a contender upgrade.
J.J. McCarthy (age 23): the long-horizon fit is strong (rebuild score 75.3/100), but production (24.6/100) hasn't matched the name value. He grades 29.
Next move lives on your imported desk — open the league and match contender vs rebuilder, not a generic chart.
1QB and Superflex are the two formats most leagues use; SF TE Premium boosts elite tight ends. Compare against the full trade value chart.
Values are our own: talent (production weighted against draft pedigree), age curve, role security, upside, contract, and risk, scaled by format scarcity. We do not sell or republish consensus ranks. Scale: 0–100 base, open-ended after format adjustment. Read the methodology.